electionline Weekly - November 16, 2006
From electionline.org
- Thursday, November 16, 2006
electionline Weekly - November 16, 2006 electionline.org
I. In Focus This Week
Election Day with Chuck and Tom 100 minutes at Colorado's vote centers, or 'A Tale of Two Counties' M. Mindy Moretti electionline.org They were the longest of lines and they were the shortest of lines. There was coffee being sold; there weren't enough places to sit down. They had a 90 minute wait before them; they had less than a 10 minute wait before them. One was going directly to vote center heaven and one, well, was not going that way. Chuck Woodford and Tom Koetting, college buddies from West Virginia University, now live about 60 miles apart in Colorado - Chuck in Denver and Tom in Larimer County. Although they've shared many similar experiences in life - college, career, family - what they experienced on Election Day 2006 couldn't have been more different. Washington Park Recreation Center, Denver Chuck decided to vote at the Washington Park Recreation Center because it's about a mile from his home. He arrived at the vote center around noon and encountered a lengthy line. He waited about 45 minutes just to get into the gymnasium where the voting was taking place. Once inside the gym, Chuck got into another line to check in for voting. There were about 10 people left in front him before it was his turn to check in when suddenly, all activity seemed to halt inside the polling place. After advancing no further in line for several minutes Chuck and others in began to sense there was a problem. And what a problem it was. The system to check in voters had gone down citywide. About five chairs were offered, but not nearly enough for the many people in line. As time wore on folks waiting in line began to talk. When one voter took out his cell phone and placed a call, a volunteer quickly came and told him that talking on phones in the polling place - even with the voting halted - was discouraged. "As you can imagine after waiting so long in line we all did start casually talking to one another, just flippant comments from time to time, nothing too deep or personal. One man in front of me said, 'We should be using paper ballots.' I called him a misguided visionary and we had a brief laugh at that," Chuck said. Time began to drag on and Chuck, who has a two-year old son, marveled at the overall patience and good will of his fellow voters, especially the children accompanying their parents. "I was pleasantly surprised at how tolerant we all were of the computer delay," Chuck said. "Now, granted we were about 15 feet away from the crashed computers so we could watch the progress as it happened. I'm sure it must have been very frustrating out in the hallway wondering what was going on." During his more than 30 minute wait for the computers to come back up, Chuck said he only saw one voter walk away - a gentleman who ripped up his voter card and threw it in the trash as he left the building. Once the computer system was back up and running, Chuck quickly made his way to the voting machine where he cast his ballot and headed about his day. "After check-in, I immediately went to a voting station and cast my ballot with no trouble whatsoever. One of the volunteers escorted me to the station and talked me through the whole process, what buttons to press, how to change my mind and how to cast my vote once I had finished marking my ballot," Chuck said. "The voting process itself was flawless; it was just getting to that point which was obnoxious." So, after all of that, what does Chuck think of the new vote center concept? "I understand the vote center concept as it cuts down drastically on the number of volunteers needed but, seriously, how do you not then stock up on as many laptops and check-in volunteers as you possibly can at each center?" Chuck asked. "I absolutely will not think twice about voting next time, I'll just be a bit smarter as to when I go vote. And I'll make sure I have a good two-plus hours to do it." Total time to vote: 90 minutes. Ace Hardware, Harmony Road, Larimer County In Larimer County, where the voter center concept originated more than two years ago, Tom went to a vote center at the Ace Hardware shopping center on Harmony Rd. around 10:45 a.m. Tom and his wife took time off from work so they could vote together. They chose the vote center in the shopping center because it was close to their home and had plenty of available parking. This wasn't the first time Tom had used a vote center - he voted at the same shopping center in 2004 - so he knew what to expect. The first time used a vote center he "thought it was heaven. What smart person figured this out?" When Tom and his wife arrived, the line was about 40-people deep, but moving quickly. Tom noticed that while a man was attempting to sell coffee to voters, the line was moving too quickly for anyone to stop and buy any. Tom and his wife were checked in quickly, voted and were out the door quickly. So impressed by the experience, Tom said has crossed party lines to support County Clerk Scott Doyle (R), the man who implemented vote centers in Larimer. "Voting was as smooth as glass in America's best voting county," Tom said "Scott Doyle is a great clerk. I voted for him again. Not all of my votes went to the left. Sometimes good government is just good government." Total time to vote: 15 minutes.
Vote brings turnover in top election jobs
Doug Chapin electionline.org
The 2006 vote opened the door to changes in future elections as voters picked new secretaries of state in 12 states - including changes of party in seven states. Though the jobs have a number of other facets, many of the campaigns for the position focused extensively on election administration issues, especially in states where incumbent secretaries were defeated for re-election: - In California, Secretary Bruce McPherson (R) was defeated by State Senator Debra Bowen (D) in a race that focused largely on McPherson's management of the state's election system. Bowen campaigned on improving the scrutiny of touch-screen voting machines - a subject that can now be expected to get increased policy attention in the Golden State. Interestingly, McPherson's only television advertisement focused not on voting technology but voter ID - a popular issue for many Republicans nationwide.
- In Minnesota, incumbent Mary Kiffmeyer (R) was overtaken by challenger Mark Ritchie (D) in a contest that focused extensively on Ritchie's allegations that Kiffmeyer was too focused on fraud and thus failing to properly carry out her election-related duties as Secretary. Ritchie got some high-profile assistance from a predecessor in the form of a television spot featuring former Secretary of State Joan Growe.
- In Alabama, Secretary of State Nancy Worley (D) lost to State Auditor Beth Chapman (R) in a race that focused on Worley's fiscal management of her office. Worley was also hurt by the ongoing federal lawsuit over Alabama's non-compliance with the Help America Vote Act database requirement. In addition to two negative ads, Chapman ran a TV commercial in which she said "stealing your vote is like stealing your money" and promising to push for voter ID.
In four other states, the incumbent's bid for another office opened up the seat to a party switch. While Democrats succeeded in their bids to retake Congress, battles for top election posts resulted in a tie in four states: - In Georgia, Fulton County Executive Karen Handel (R) will assume the job after outgoing Secretary of State Cathy Cox (D) lost her bid for the state's gubernatorial nomination - a potentially key development given Cox's leading role in opposing the state's new photo ID requirement.
- In Louisiana, State Senator Jay Dardenne (R) won an open seat race to replace Al Ater (D), who declined to seek re-election after he was appointed to fill the vacancy created by the death of his good friend, former Secretary of State Fox McKeithen.
- In Nevada, Secretary Dean Heller left his job to run a successful campaign for the U.S. House of Representatives - his replacement will be Clark County Deputy District Attorney Ross Miller (D).
- In Ohio, Secretary of State Kenneth Blackwell (R) was defeated in his gubernatorial bid, with his seat going to election lawyer Jennifer Brunner (D).
In five other states, outgoing Secretaries were replaced with candidates of the same party: - In Colorado, State Treasurer Mike Coffman (R) - who re-enlisted with the Marine Corps and assisted with the electoral process in Iraq - will replace Gigi Dennis after winning a narrow victory over Senate Majority Leader Tom Gordon (D) clouded by voting problems in Denver.
- Polk County, Iowa Auditor Mike Mauro (D) will replace Chet Culver, who was elected Governor;
- In New Mexico, Bernalillo County Clerk Mary Herrera (D) will replace term-limited Rebecca Vigil-Giron;
- In Rhode Island, North Providence Mayor Ralph Mollis (D) will replace Matthew Brown; and
- In Wyoming, State Auditor Max Maxfield (R) will replace Joe Meyer, who was elected State Treasurer.
Further changes are also possible as new governors, mayors and state and local officials make their decisions about retaining or removing the men and women responsible for managing elections at the state and local level.
II. Election Reform News This Week - The first recount in the contested race in Sarasota County, Fla. ended Tuesday with no major changes and no additional answers to why more than 18,000 under votes were recorded in the race for the 13th Congressional district. Sarasota elections supervisor Kathy Dent told the Associated Press that the initial recount proved the touch-screen machines performed "flawlessly' while the few small mistakes in the count were attributed to the machines that scan absentee ballots and to poll worker error. A manual recount, which critics say is useless without a voter-verified paper audit trail, began today. MIT professor Ted Selker told The Miami Herald earlier this week that the design of the ballot, which was a "poster child" for poor ballot design, might have been what led to the high number of under votes in the hotly contested race for the 13th Congressional District. A second recount started Thursday. Citing the questions over this election, Rep. Rush Holt, D-N.J., reiterated a call to pass his bill (H.R. 550) mandating paper trails for electronic voting.
- Wayne Vaden, Denver's clerk and recorder as well as the only full-time member of the Election Commission, resigned this week, taking his "fair share of the responsibility" for the problems encountered on Election Day in Denver, but also citing problems with the city's elections system.
III. Opinion This Week
National: Election Day, II, electronic voting, voting security, Diebold, uniform rules, voting systems Colorado: Election Day, Problems in Denver II, Problems in Montrose County, vote by mail Florida: Electronic voting, VVPAT, vote counting, revote, poll workers Illinois: Cook County Clerk Indiana: Election Day, vote centers, vote by mail Maryland: Montgomery County Montana: Voter confidence New York: Voting technology North Carolina: Election process, voting upgrades Ohio: Funding Oregon: Vote by mail Pennsylvania: Paper ballots, Franklin County, voting machines Tennessee: Paper ballots, voting machines Some sites require registration
electionline Weekly and electionline.org ALERTS are produced by the staff of electionline.org, a non-partisan, non-advocacy research effort supported by The Pew Charitable Trusts and administered by the University of Richmond . More information about the Project and up-to-the-minute news on election reform throughout the week can be found at electionline.org.
Read More
[ permalink ]
|